What should financial regulatory reform look like? Treasury Secretary Timothy F. Geithner has announced the outlines of a plan, and Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke has testified to its benefits. There is a lot to their proposal, parts of which are quite new, and other parts that have been around for some time.
Financial reform always works this way. It follow crises, like the panic of 1907 that led to the establishment of the Federal Reserve, the 1929 stock market crash that lead to the creation of the Securities and Exchange Commission, and the collapse of Enron and WorldCom that resulted in the passage of Sarbanes-Oxley in 2002. Reform proposals, on the other hand, are less cyclical, and so they tend to accumulate in the crisis interstices, waiting for the critical legislative mass for enactment that only a panic, apparently, can bring.
The legislative cycle means that one of the fundamental ideas in Geithner’s plan has been around for some time. The consolidation of regulation and creation of a systemic regulator is something that Americans have been talking about for years. The Europeans have urged it upon us for at least as long. On the other hand, a second reform proposal, that banks should be permanently de-levered, strikes me as quite new, quite tailored to the particular perceived flaws that led to the current crisis, and decidedly un-European. Both reforms have some slightly counter intuitive implications.
Leverage Caps
The locus of a not-very-European rule that would impose leverage caps on banks could be, interestingly enough, in Switzerland, where the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision can be found. Why would Basel be the place for the de-levering regime, rather than the Fed? It could be that American regulators believe that, in the end, putting together the domestic political will to cut down monster banks would be, in the end, quite difficult. Or it could be that the prospect of competing with super-large European and Japanese institutions is unpalatable, creating the need for a global rule.
Basel is not without its accomplishments, and, somewhat counter intuitively, the fact that some of the failures of regulation during the financial crisis attest to this. After all, the first financial institutions to fail were, at least in the view of the SEC, adequately capitalized under Basel II up to the moment they failed. This was the case for both Bear Stearns and Lehman Brothers. There is no question that the Basel II will be reevaluated sooner than later, but perhaps one lesson of the crisis is how important this relatively young international institution is: It was the Basel Committee that set the standards that Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers, and the big European banks met in practice, and it was Basel II that did not, in the end, sufficiently keep the banks solvent.
Nonetheless, Basel has been very quiet since the failure of Bear Stearns. It has produced speeches on the importance of coordinated supervision, and has announced far-off deadline plans to rethink the basics of capital adequacy supervision. Its recent decision to expand the size of the group to something that resembles the G20 underscores just how important the G20 has become vis a vis Basel. What Basel has not done is provide a means of coordinated crisis response. That silence at Basel on that score is quite notable, since Basel was created to do something about international banking crises, and the prevention of them is its raison d’etre.
For that reason, as well as for the rule-oriented leverage-cap concept, a decision to give the Basel Committee something to do is quite notable in and of itself. But the substantial importance of the rule makes it only more so. Even though the Basel Committee has played a relatively minor role thus far in responding to the crisis, the decision will cheer proponents of global coordination to hear that it may be tasked with an important part of the solution. Leverage caps means that Basel does not appear to be gone from an important place on the national stage.
Systemic Regulator
What about the older idea: a consolidated regulator modeled on Britain’s Financial Services Authority? The politics of making such a regulator happen may turn on who trusts the Federal Reserve. It is a likely home for a systemic regulator, though Geithner’s proposal has been coy about where, exactly, that regulator might be.
The Fed is not the only home that has been proposed. In Henry Paulson's blueprint, financial regulation would have – it seems, at least – been centralized in the Treasury Department. Paul Volcker, with Geithner's pre-appointment approval, also wanted to centralize and consolidate the American regulatory apparatus, but apparently in an independent regulator – he may have been thinking of the Fed -- more resistant to the political winds than Treasury.
If one way to understand the Geithner plan, and financial reform more generally, is to think of it as a set of options, three options look like this: keep the regulatory system as either fragmented, the way it was, semi-centralized, the way it has become during this crisis, or bureaucratized and rationalized, along the lines that Paulson, Volcker, and now Bernanke and Geithner seem to suggest.
A lot of people want that Weberian rationalization. But really, there is a very long pedigree for the system we used to have - decentralized, functionalist, open to regulatory competition and races to the top. Amid all the cries for reform, the advantages of mess -- that is, a system where small states like Delaware play roles along with the federal government, where agencies like the SEC and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) compete for business - are easy to overlook.
After all, super-regulators don't face competitive pressure to be good regulators, unless you believe that globalization can provide that competition.
But there is a final candidate for the home of the systemic regulator, and it is looking like quite a strong one. The President's Working Group already requires the patchwork quilt of regulators that we now have to meet. Perhaps the President's Working Group will be given the job of systemic regulation, which would make this reform just regulation by committee with monthly meetings.
Entrusting the President’s Working Group with the role of systemic risk regulation is not likely to create over-regulation, or overweening, powerful financial bureaucrats. And it is less independent, and bank-focused, than the Fed.
The problem, however, is that it may not be much of a change at all.
Author bio
David Zaring is Assistant Professor of Law at the Wharton School of Business. His research is focused on international economic regulation and administrative law. He has published articles in the NYU, Michigan, and UCLA law reviews, and in peer-reviewed journals including the Annual Review of Law & Social Science, the Journal of Tort Law and the Journal of Empirical Legal Studies. He clerked on the D.C. Circuit, worked at the Department of Justice, and was educated at Harvard Law School and Swarthmore College.
Comments
asics for sale
asics for sale
ugg boots sale
Links
- High Heel Shoes
- NFL Jersey
- Mbt shoes
- Christian Louboutin
- Wholesale china
- Wholesale Women Shoes
- Wholesale Christian Louboutin
- Wholesale Jimmy Choo
- Wholesale Jordans Shoes
- Wholesale Manolo Blahnik
- wholesale mbt shoes
- Wholesale Yves Saint Laurent
- Wholesale NFl Jerseys
- Wholesale Nike Shoes
- Wholesale UGG Boots
Men MBT Sandals , discount MBT Sandals mbt sandals, cheap mbt sandals , mbt sandals shoes,,chung shi sandals, MBT Sandals mbt sandals reviews,Discount MBT Shoes mbt sandals on sale with free shipping. Clothing and Accessories - Free Shipping BOTH ways. Mbt shoes is the first physiological footwear that has a positive effect on the whole body. Vikings Jersey-Minnesota Vikings Jersey If you've been looking for purple or white Chicago Bears Jersey ,we've done that for you.Carolina Panthers Jersey You can find any Vikings player's jersey you want. Welcome to jerseys-shopping nfl jerseys store. New York Giants JerseyAs the world-leading NFL Jerseys store, we supply more than 700 high-quality merchandise discount NFL Jersey of NFL. Our website is revising, green bay packers Jersey">New York Giants Jersey I hope everyone can enjoy this layout. At the same time, we will keep on working hard for everyone to provide a better shopping experience. Discount UGG BootsWholesale Clothing
CA Bikini
Wholesale Handbags
Wholesale Jewelry
china wholesale
wholesale products suppliers
wholesale MBT Shoes
wholesale china
china wholesalers
NBA jerseys MLB jerseys NHL jerseys NFL Jerseys
nfl jerseys
Vibram Five Fingers
MBT Shoes
Jordan Shoes
Nike Shoes
Christian Louboutin Shoes
UGG Boots
Jimmy Choo Shoes
Wholesale Rolex Watches
Tiffany Jewelry
GHD Hair Straighteners
Oakley Sunglasses
Wholesale Sunglasses
cheap Gucci Shoes
discount mbt shoes
cheap Nike Shoes
Timberland Boots
Discount UGG Boots
cheap Gucci Shoes
Christian Louboutin boots
Ed Hardy Clothing
Polo Clothing
lv handbag
Chanel handbag
Tiffany Jewelry
CHI Hair Straighteners
Rolex Watches
cheap mbt chapa gtx
MBT Kisumu Sandals
Mbt m walk sky
wholesale jordan shoes
wholesale Timberland Shoes
wholesale Lacoste Shoes
wholesale Bape Shoes
wholesale ED Hardy Shoes
Nike Air Force one Shoes
wholesale Adidas Shoes
wholesale Nike Air Yeezy
wholesale Air Max shoes
wholesale shox shoes
wholesale Puma Shoes
wholesale D&G Jeans
wholesale Bape Jeans
wholesale Coogi Jeans
wholesale Armani Jeans
wholesale Christian Audigier wholesale Ed Hardy Jeans wholesale True Religion Jeans wholesale GUCCI Bags wholesale d&g handbags wholesale ED Hardy handbags wholesale Tous handbags LV women handbags miu miu handbags wholesale chanel women handbags wholesale gucci ladies handbag wholesale Fendi women handbags wholesale d&g handbags wholesale YSL handabgs NFL jerseys for sale nike Air Force one wholesale nike dunk SB wholesale nfl jerseys nfl jerseys cheap nfl jersey sales Nike air max 90 nfl jerseys wholesale nfl jersey sizes ugg boots sale wholesale ugg boot sale ugg sundance boots ugg classic short ugg classic tall newest style ugg boots ugg classic mini ugg ultra short ugg cardy nike blazers shoes UGG Highkoo wholesale UGG Elsey UGG Nightfall china wholesale products Christian Louboutin Specials china wholesale shoes UGG Classic Crochet UGG boots wholesale nike blazers shoes ugg highkoo ugg elsey ugg nightfall china wholesale products christian louboutin specials china wholesale shoes ugg classic crochet ugg boots wholesale wholesale GUCCI handbags wholesale clothing wholesale shoes wholesale handbags wholesale GUCCI handbags Nike Shoes mbt Shoes Jordan Shoes Supra Shoes Vibram Five Fingers AF T Shirts Polo tshirt Ed Hardy Clothing Christian Louboutin wholesale MBT Shoes UGG Boots Yves Saint Laurent Abercrombie Fitch Clothing edhard bikini wholesale Chanel handbangs wholesale Versace handbangs small wholesale Dolce Gabbana handbangs Louboutin Shoes Discount Louboutin Shoes High Heel Shoes Christain Louboutin Slingback Womens high heel shoes christian louboutin shoes christian louboutin bridal christian louboutin pronunciation Mbt shoes mbt shoes sale Cheapest MBT Shoes Cheap Uggs Boots Buy Discount Ugg Boots Discount Ugg Boots Christian Louboutin sale MBT Shoes Cheap christian louboutin Discout High Heel Shoes high heel boots Womens high heel shoes
Tom Brady Authentic Jersey
Due to the fact that winter is on the way, so people begain to look for the winter handbags, such as the coach handbags. For these cuthentic coach handbags that sold in the online stores that really high quality as well as the fashion trend. To buy he coach handbags at lower price, then our website would be your best choice. We provide the authentic coach handbagsfor sale, definitely you get the cheap coach handbags than get from the retailers. It is household that the coach handbags outlet that also provide excellent handbags. So it is worth for you to buy the Coach handbags outletin our website, the authentic coach handbags that sold here come along with the Coach luggage bags.
nfl jersesy cheap
cheap online shopping sites
In honor of New Year, our nike shox sale store hold nike shox clearance activity. As we know, the cheap nike shox come with guaranteed quality and reasonable price make it pervasive in many countries, especially America. Shox columns heel come with square form with four columns provide best stability, which is partly the reason why the nike shox r4 is so popular as sport shoes, so is nike shox nz. The shox series adopts a revolutionary technology and make the sport shoes stand out from other sneakers. The nike shox deliver is also very salable, and the selling point is its sleek and classy appearance. The nike shox tl3 is unique for the newfangled heel.
It is also good news for the UGG fans that our store released ugg boots clearance in order to thanks to the new and old customers. The classic cardy ugg boots and ugg bailey button triplet, which are the red-hot ugg boots for women of 2010, is on sale for clearance now. UGG bailey button on sale will for sure make this item the hottest in 2011. There are many ugg classic tall sale is on discount now.
Apart from this, you can get the most competitive price of ugg boots for kids, the ugg boots on sale also include the childrens ugg boots. All cheap ugg boots online is waiting for you.
Cheap Jordans
We are wholesale all kinds of Cheap Jordan Shoes,if you looking more Jordan shoes online,welcome to our shoes online store,have lots of Cheap Jordans for you,new styles of Air Jordan 6,Air Jordan 11,Air Jordan 12,Air Jordan 13,Air Jordan 23,Air Jordan 5 etc top quality Jordans Shoes save 70% off hot selling.
Professional supply all kinds of Puma shoes with cheap price and top customer rater service,if you looking more cheap Puma shoes on sale,welcome to our Puma outlet online store choose the Puma sneakers.All the Puma running shoes are with original package.Our Puma Store have lots of new arrival Puma Ferrari,Puma Suede,Puma Speed Cat,Puma Future Cat,and Puma Ducati etc Pumas save more 70% cheap for you.
Thanks for your article! This is my point
Cheap Jordans
We are wholesale all kinds of Cheap Jordan Shoes,if you looking more Jordan shoes online,welcome to our shoes online store,have lots of Cheap Jordans for you,new styles of Air Jordan 6,Air Jordan 11,Air Jordan 12,Air Jordan 13,Air Jordan 23,Air Jordan 5 etc top quality Jordans Shoes save 70% off hot selling.
Professional supply all kinds of Puma shoes with cheap price and top customer rater service,if you looking more cheap Puma shoes on sale,welcome to our Puma outlet online store choose the Puma sneakers.All the Puma running shoes are with original package.Our Puma Store have lots of new arrival Puma Ferrari,Puma Suede,Puma Speed Cat,Puma Future Cat,and Puma Ducati etc Pumas save more 70% cheap for you.
Thanks for your article! This is my point
bridesmaid dresses 2011
British Advertising Standards Authority said that although the evidence that louis vuitton online offers a lot of technology in production the use of hand-made production, but not enough to prove these products are handmade louis vuitton online outlet. Advertising Standards Authority said: "We find that we had not seen the louis vuitton outlet products through the production of detailed documentation, and does not know the production of hand and machine, or the proportion lv online .
Louis Vuitton Outlet,Louis Vuitton bags, the majority of customers buy the product this information to him not to create further said. The British Advertising Standards Authority for misleading advertising by considering prohibiting advertising louis vuitton online, as well as more cheap Louis Vuitton than looks girlfriend pay more attention to other things, would like
Patriots Jersey
Acheter Doudoune Moncler
Doudoune Monclertoits exigences en cours de production et de certainstravaux. Mais maintenant vous pouvez Acheter Doudoune Moncler en ligne. Notre boutique en ligne offre un moyen simple d'acquérir contacter par marquemerveilleux.
Sacs Louis Vuittonest vraiment axé sur la marque bien reconnue, une eurdecraftsmanship produit.Louis Vuitton Speedyest reconnu comme la séquence des LV.Go fot bientôt.
LeLongchamp Moins Chersont populaires dans l'clients.ChooseSacs Longchamp , produisant un superbe taste.You ne peut pas négliger l'occasion.

VOB to FLV Converter/ FLV to WMV Converter/ FLV to VOB Converter/bridal dresses
with the winged hourglass as its emblem, the brand watch replicas has breitling watches for sale outlets in over 130 countries.
the omega watch company began in 1848 and continues to manufacture sports and dress watches for women and men. sold at department mens watches stores and select jewelry stores worldwide, the company offers a wide variety of watch styles and functions. the omega self-winding watch series features a power reserve of 50 hours and precision mechanics in movado replica styles available for both men and women. there are only a few steps required to start an omega self-winding watch. since this complication mens luxury watches is by definition focused on defining short times, the designers decided to watch for sale concentrate on the minutes and seconds to ensure optimal legibility.