By Janet Morrissey
The SEC internal-investigation report released on Wednesday points a clear finger of blame at the
agency, stating that SEC investigators missed multiple opportunities to discover Bernard Madoff's
criminal activities.
But while the report hammers the SEC for repeated instances of incompetence, it stops well short
of declaring the SEC liable. "The OIG [Office of Inspector General] investigation did not find
evidence that any SEC personnel who worked on an SEC examination or investigation of Bernard
L. Madoff Investment Securities LLC had any financial or other inappropriate connection with
Bernard Madoff or the Madoff family that influenced the conduct of their examination or
investigatory work," the report notes. (See a Madoff family photo album.)
In perhaps the biggest nod to SEC culpability, the OIG report says the SEC's futile investigations of
Madoff were ultimately used by Madoff as a means of reassuring clients that his operations were
clean, and these "had the effect of encouraging additional individuals and entities to invest with
him."
Howard Elisofan, a partner at Herrick, Feinstein LLP and a former SEC enforcement attorney,
launched a legal action against the SEC on behalf of a victim, Phyllis Molchatsky, last December.
He has since filed eight similar complaints. "We're arguing that the SEC was negligent on multiple
occasions for many reasons over multiple years, and had they detected the fraud a long time ago,
thousands of people would not have been so gravely injured," he said.
Suing a government entity isn't easy, though. The process involves filing an administrative claim
for relief, which, if rejected by the SEC, would allow the suit to be fought in federal district court.
When a court decision is rendered, the appeal process often drags out for many years. (Read a
Q&A with Bernie Madoff's mistress.)
Elisofan is encouraged by the contents of the SEC report, which he says "confirms what we've
been alleging all along — that the SEC was negligent in carrying out their statutory purpose to
protect the public interest."
Yet many legal experts see suits against the SEC as a steep uphill battle because government
entities enjoy sovereign immunity. "To sue the government is a very tough proposition," says Dan
Reinberg, a partner at Polsinelli Shughart PC. He adds that government entities have sovereign
immunity for good reason. "The regulators are there to do a job that the public has asked them to
do, and if they can be sued for negligence or mismanagement in their official function, then who's
going to want to be a regulator?" he asks.
Overcoming the sovereign-immunity protection is the biggest hurdle, concurs David Bernfeld, a
partner at Bernfeld Dematteo & Bernfeld LLC, who represents about a dozen Madoff victims.
However, he believes the inspector general's report offers enough ammunition to prove negligence
— which is the bullet needed to pierce the sovereign-immunity defense and make the SEC liable.
"The report was really candid. It's an astonishing litany of indifference and ineptitude" that
occurred over a long period of time, Bernfeld says. "And this should be helpful in getting past the
sovereign-immunity defense because it makes clear that this was not simply a decision not to
investigate — it was a series of investigations undertaken but negligently performed."
However, Jim Rickards, a senior managing partner at Omnis Inc. and a former general counsel
for Long Term Capital Management who helped negotiate a federal bailout for the failed hedge
fund in 1998, isn't so sure the report's findings will be enough to make the SEC liable.
"The hurdle under the statute is so high — they have to show that there was an SEC rule that
required them to go forward," he says. "They may have missed a lot of clues and the people were
not diligent in following up on leads, but none of that shows they violated an internal rule because
there's always discretion."
The SEC gets many tips, good and bad, and can't be expected to follow up on every single one,
Rickards contends. "They get tips all the time — some of them are invented, some of them are
malicious, some of them are people who are out to destroy other people, and they try to use the
SEC as the enforcement agency," he says. "So they don't act on all of it. That's where the discretion
comes in, and that's why in my view the suit will fall down."
"It's extremely unlikely" the SEC will be held liable, Rickards says.
David Schindler, a partner at Latham & Watkins who specializes in white collar and government
investigations, says "human frailty" will always be a factor, and that would hold true even if
tougher regulations and oversights had been in force over the past decade. "When you're a
regulator and you get an allegation of wrongdoing [regarding] somebody who occupied the
position in Nasdaq that Madoff did at that time, the human condition is such that it might be hard
for somebody to start investigating or shooting at someone of his stature [knowing that] if they're
wrong, their career and others may suffer," says Schindler. Whether a federal court will hold the
SEC accountable for the "human failings of one or more personnel" is the question, he says. If it
does, though, he says the ruling would open the floodgates for people to make claims in every
Ponzi scheme.
David Evans, managing director at consulting firm LECG, founder of Market Platform Dynamics
and editor of FinReg21.com, says there's no doubt the SEC was asleep at the wheel during the
Madoff crisis. However, he believes it's next to impossible to sue a government entity and thinks it
would be better if Congress stepped up to help out the victims similar to the way it assisted the
automakers and others. He suggests financial assistance be limited to victims that are either
nonprofit organizations or have income under a certain threshold.
"There would be a backlash to Congress bailing out billionaires who lost a few hundred million as
a result of the Madoff scandal," says Evans. "But there are people who are affected by the Ponzi
scheme who I think we all agree are deserving of a helping hand."
Still, some legal eagles believe Congress could set a dangerous precedent if it approved a bailout
package for Madoff victims.
"Lots of people lose lots of money due to frauds every year — and so aside from the magnitude of
the fraud, it's difficult to find a justification to treat Madoff's victims different than the victims of
the Worldcom fraud or Enron," says Chris Clark, a partner at Dewey & LeBoeuf LLP. "I don't
mean to sound unsympathetic, but it's difficult for me to imagine that Congress would legislate
relief for one group of aggrieved investors when people lost billions of dollars in Lehman Brothers.
Are they going to pass a statute that says you get your money back if you lost it at Lehman?"
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Time - MadoffVictimsSueSEC.pdf | 44.95 KB |
Comments
123
MBT 店舗
timberland
air max 95
UGG
Links
- High Heel Shoes
- NFL Jersey
- Mbt shoes
- Christian Louboutin
- Wholesale china
- Wholesale Women Shoes
- Wholesale Christian Louboutin
- Wholesale Jimmy Choo
- Wholesale Jordans Shoes
- Wholesale Manolo Blahnik
- wholesale mbt shoes
- Wholesale Yves Saint Laurent
- Wholesale NFl Jerseys
- Wholesale Nike Shoes
- Wholesale UGG Boots
Men MBT Sandals , discount MBT Sandals mbt sandals, cheap mbt sandals , mbt sandals shoes,,chung shi sandals, MBT Sandals mbt sandals reviews,Discount MBT Shoes mbt sandals on sale with free shipping. Clothing and Accessories - Free Shipping BOTH ways. Mbt shoes is the first physiological footwear that has a positive effect on the whole body. Vikings Jersey-Minnesota Vikings Jersey If you've been looking for purple or white Chicago Bears Jersey ,we've done that for you.Carolina Panthers Jersey You can find any Vikings player's jersey you want. Welcome to jerseys-shopping nfl jerseys store. New York Giants JerseyAs the world-leading NFL Jerseys store, we supply more than 700 high-quality merchandise discount NFL Jersey of NFL. Our website is revising, green bay packers Jersey">New York Giants Jersey I hope everyone can enjoy this layout. At the same time, we will keep on working hard for everyone to provide a better shopping experience. Discount UGG BootsWholesale Clothing
CA Bikini
Wholesale Handbags
Wholesale Jewelry
china wholesale
wholesale products suppliers
wholesale MBT Shoes
wholesale china
china wholesalers
NBA jerseys MLB jerseys NHL jerseys NFL Jerseys
nfl jerseys
Vibram Five Fingers
MBT Shoes
Jordan Shoes
Nike Shoes
Christian Louboutin Shoes
UGG Boots
Jimmy Choo Shoes
Wholesale Rolex Watches
Tiffany Jewelry
GHD Hair Straighteners
Oakley Sunglasses
Wholesale Sunglasses
cheap Gucci Shoes
discount mbt shoes
cheap Nike Shoes
Timberland Boots
Discount UGG Boots
cheap Gucci Shoes
Christian Louboutin boots
Ed Hardy Clothing
Polo Clothing
lv handbag
Chanel handbag
Tiffany Jewelry
CHI Hair Straighteners
Rolex Watches
cheap mbt chapa gtx
MBT Kisumu Sandals
Mbt m walk sky
wholesale jordan shoes
wholesale Timberland Shoes
wholesale Lacoste Shoes
wholesale Bape Shoes
wholesale ED Hardy Shoes
Nike Air Force one Shoes
wholesale Adidas Shoes
wholesale Nike Air Yeezy
wholesale Air Max shoes
wholesale shox shoes
wholesale Puma Shoes
wholesale D&G Jeans
wholesale Bape Jeans
wholesale Coogi Jeans
wholesale Armani Jeans
wholesale Christian Audigier wholesale Ed Hardy Jeans wholesale True Religion Jeans wholesale GUCCI Bags wholesale d&g handbags wholesale ED Hardy handbags wholesale Tous handbags LV women handbags miu miu handbags wholesale chanel women handbags wholesale gucci ladies handbag wholesale Fendi women handbags wholesale d&g handbags wholesale YSL handabgs NFL jerseys for sale nike Air Force one wholesale nike dunk SB wholesale nfl jerseys nfl jerseys cheap nfl jersey sales Nike air max 90 nfl jerseys wholesale nfl jersey sizes ugg boots sale wholesale ugg boot sale ugg sundance boots ugg classic short ugg classic tall newest style ugg boots ugg classic mini ugg ultra short ugg cardy nike blazers shoes UGG Highkoo wholesale UGG Elsey UGG Nightfall china wholesale products Christian Louboutin Specials china wholesale shoes UGG Classic Crochet UGG boots wholesale nike blazers shoes ugg highkoo ugg elsey ugg nightfall china wholesale products christian louboutin specials china wholesale shoes ugg classic crochet ugg boots wholesale wholesale GUCCI handbags wholesale clothing wholesale shoes wholesale handbags wholesale GUCCI handbags Nike Shoes mbt Shoes Jordan Shoes Supra Shoes Vibram Five Fingers AF T Shirts Polo tshirt Ed Hardy Clothing Christian Louboutin wholesale MBT Shoes UGG Boots Yves Saint Laurent Abercrombie Fitch Clothing edhard bikini wholesale Chanel handbangs wholesale Versace handbangs small wholesale Dolce Gabbana handbangs Louboutin Shoes Discount Louboutin Shoes High Heel Shoes Christain Louboutin Slingback Womens high heel shoes christian louboutin shoes christian louboutin bridal christian louboutin pronunciation Mbt shoes mbt shoes sale Cheapest MBT Shoes Cheap Uggs Boots Buy Discount Ugg Boots Discount Ugg Boots Christian Louboutin sale MBT Shoes Cheap christian louboutin Discout High Heel Shoes high heel boots Womens high heel shoes
We have Snow boots sale in variety to fit your style. All our EMU boots collection have covered a foam backing with genuine sheepskin and a molded EVA lightweight and flexible sole with each step for amazing comfort.
When you wear Sheepskin Boots , your feet feel clean and fresh throughout the day.Ugg Roseberry Boots and Ugg Suburb Crochet Boots are ideal for indoor and outdoor wear.In many cases, the particular style of UGG boot worn by these women is the UGG Knightsbridge boot and Ugg Mayfaire Short Boots
只要人人都献出一点爱世界将变成美好的人间!
Christian Louboutin Shoes
MBT shoes TEMBEA
MBT Sports Shoes
MBT Casual Shoes
MBT Barabara shoes
MBT casual shoes
MBT Changa shoes
MBT Lami shoes
MBT shoes VOI
MBT sports shoes
MBT Tembea shoes
MBT Womens 9125
MBT Barabara shoes
MBT casual shoes
MBT Changa shoes
MBT Lami shoes
MBT shoes VOI
MBT sports shoes
MBT Tembea shoes
Louboutin Shoes
Bridal Gowns
Christian Louboutin Boots
Girls High Heels
nike air jordans 23
High heel boots
links of london
High Heels and stockings
Wholesale Christian Louboutin
Cheap MBT Shoes On Sale
China Bags Wholesale
discount-gucci-handbags
Iphone 4gb Review
discount jimmy choo
edhardy shoes shop
hobo brand handbags
fake handbags wholesale
louis vuitton handbags shop
jordans shoes
wholesale chloe handbags
miu miu shoes shop
d'Orsays Mary Janes Slingback Wedges Evening
Kids' Nike Air Jordan Sneakers (9)Men's Air Jordan 1 Shoes (25)
Men's Air Jordan 2.5 (5)
Men's Nike Air Jordans 3 (11)
Men's Nike Air Jordan 4.5+13 (1)
Men's Nike Air Jordan 5 Sneakers (7)
Alexander Mcquee Dkny shoes Yves Saint Laurent MANOLO BLAHNIk Chanel Coach shoes Dior shoes Fendi shoes Prada Burberry MBT shoes Shuguli GTX
Replica Rolex watches
Thanks for sharing this article.
designer Tiffany jewelry
We are professional supply ugg boots ,have lots brand new cheap uggs ,all the sheepskin boots are popular winter boots , the ugg classic tall is the hot selling of the snow boots ,these cheap ugg boots are come with high uality Australia sheepskin boots shoes ,also have new arrival ugg slippers ,if you want to find more discount ugg boots please feel free to contact us !
Timberland boots,Burberry bags,Prada handbags,Louis Vuitton bags,Coach handbags,Gucci bags,Chanel bags,MBT Shoes, Mens Clothing,Women Clothing,,Mens jeans,Mens Shoes,Women Shoes,Jordan Shoes,Nike Shoes,Air force one,Cheap UGG Boots,Cheap UGGS,Lacoste,Lacoste Shoes Etc.gucci outlet online
asd
fsda
sdd321
Even if
ustiffanymall
http://www.newbelstaff.com/
cheap ghd straighteners wholesale
Have you ever used curling hair with straighteners? If so, I'm sure you will know something about pink ghd straighteners and hair straighteners UK. The all belonged to cheap ghd straighteners.Ghd iv styler mk4 pink and ghd pretty in pink are the most welcome by our girls, while GHD IV Mini Styler is loved by more men. If you want to buy your ghd salon straighteners these days, before you place your order online, you should consider something for buying your good cheap straighteners. More and more women show their high opinions to Ghd iv salon styler. If you have thick and long hairs, you also could choose this kinds of mk4 hair straighteners for your first choice.
nike store
replikate uhren
replika uhren
replica uhren
uhren replica
uhr replica
swiss uhren
uhren online shop
uhren replikate
uhren replicas
patek philippe uhren
patek philippe nautilus
patek philipp uhren
patek philippe preisliste
hamilton uhren
hamilton uhr
romain jerome
baume et mercier uhren
baume mercier uhr
baume & mercier uhren
uhren graham
replica graham
graham replica
graham uhren
jaeger lecoultre compressor
jaeger lecoultre kaufen
jaeger lecoultre uhr
Jaeger LeCoultre uhren
jaeger lecoultre compressor
jaeger lecoultre compressor
richard mille uhren
Richard Mille
u-boat uhren
uboot uhren
u boot uhren
U-Boot uhren
Wyler uhren
Hublot uhren
uhren porsche design
orfina porsche design
porsche design indicator
patek philippe chronograph
patek philippe uhr
patek philippe calatrava
baume & mercier hampton
baume mercier uhren
baume et mercier uhren
jaeger lecoultre master
baume mercier hampton
baume und mercier uhren
Wyler
porsche uhren design
porsche design chronograph
porsche design uhr
Porsche Design uhren
porsche design flat six
uhr porsche design
porsche uhren
mbt shoes
Couture Wedding Dresses
Maternity Wedding Dresses
Modest Wedding Dresses
Simple Wedding Dresses
Casual Wedding Dresses
Beach Wedding Dresses
Wedding Dresses
Bridesmaid Dresses
Mother of the Bride Dresses
Flower Girl Dresses
Junior Bridesmaid Dresses
Wedding Party Dresses
Special Occasion Dresses
Cocktail Dresses
Evening Dresses
Homecoming Dresses
Prom Dresses
Quinceanera Dresses
Little Black Dresses
Celebrity Dresses
Wedding Accessories
cheap wedding dresses wholesale wedding dress Wedding dresses 2011 Plus Size Wedding Dress wholesale Couture Wedding Dress wholesale Formal Wedding Dress wholesale Bridesmaid Dresses wholesale Discount Bridesmaid Dress wholesale Junior Bridesmaids Dresses wholesale Maternity Bridesmaid Dress wholesale Cocktail Dress wholesale Prom Dress wholesale Evening Dress wholesale Sexy Evening Dress wholesale Stardoll Dress wholesale Quinceanera Dress wholesale Mother of the Bride Dress Flower Girl Dress Wedding Accessories wholesale
Pandora charms
Cheap True Religion Jeans
beats by dr dre pro
Acheter Doudoune Moncler
Doudoune Moncler requirements roofs being produced and certainstravaux. But now you can Acheter Doudoune Moncler online. Our online shop provides a simple to acquire contact by marquemerveilleux.
Sacs Louis Vuittonis truly focused on the well-recognized brand, a product eurdecraftsmanship.Louis Vuitton Speedyis recognized as the sequence of LV.Go fot them soon.
TheLongchamp Moins Cherare popular in clients.Choose theSacs Longchamp, producing a superb taste.You can not neglect the opportunity.